By Barrister Peter Magomu Mashate
I have read the report by COSASE indicting the leadership of the Uganda Human Rights Commission (UHRC) on the basis of what it described as ‘unjustified conflict’

This Commission chaired by Adv Mariam Wangadya has in the past two years been in the news largely not on the account of criminality on it’s side, but an internal contradiction putting three members of the commission against the Chairperson. Wangadya insists these members were fighting a proxy war.
Most important to note is the fact that these internal bickerings started shortly after Wangadya did a honourable job of helping His Excellency the President to expose the stinking corruption occasioned on the tax payer by their own representatives during the budgeting process in Parliament.
I vividly recall the arrest of three legislators including Hon. Paul Akamba, Hon. Cissy Donozio Namujju, Hon Yusuf Mutembuli (Bunyole East). Two others Micheal Mawanda and Mudimi Wamakuyu were also later arrested but on a different account under the anti corruption crusade against parliament.
Internal contradictions are not something new and to me, they serve the right purpose especially when it comes to public resources. When for example the Parliamentary Commission chaired by the former Speaker Anita Among sat to craft and advance new renumeration to themselves and the Commissioners, it was alleged that Mityana municipality MP Francis Butebi Zzaake protested the move. The end result was for him to be kicked out of the Commission. There were also attempts to have him thrown out of parliament.
Eventually, the Parliamentary Commission, with all members appearing to be ‘YES’ men and women, awarded themselves indeed SICKENING lucrative and exorbitant awards which are now being reversed by the the current leadership of parliament.
Because of lack of the Zzaakes or internal disagreements, the tax payer ended up losing billions of funds going to individual members of the Parliamentary Commission in form of Service Awards. Irregular recruitment of staff also became the order of the day, and today, what we’re seeing is a total overhaul of the chaotic leadership occasioned on the country by the ‘YES’ group in the Parliamentary Commission then.
The question therefore, is what if we had another Zzaake in that Parliamentary Commission? Would the country have lost what we lost? Or what if the new leadership of parliament headed by Rt hon. Marksons Oboth Oboth, also chose to tow the same line?
The point I am making is that no agency in government is working without internal contradictions. To the masses, these are healthy occurrences because they act as the public eyes and “checks and balances” to avoid a situation like the one which happened in the 11th Parliamentary Commission.
It is inconceivable to have a team of mature men and women sit under the same room and agree 100% day in, day out. The same goes to the Uganda Human Rights Commission.
First of all, half of the team in the UHRC are former politicians or legislators. How can one expect politicians to agree all the time with career officers? It’s very rare because the interests and aspirations of both categories are usually different. Even if they are the same, the approach to achieve those aspirations will be different!

Therefore, when I read the COSASE report recommending that Wangadya and her team of Commissioners should retire in public interest because of mere internal contradictions, I quickly concluded that our parliament is indeed “tired” or isn’t at per with the realities on the ground.
Its my considered submission that infighting is almost in every MDA but work has not stopped. Besides, the infighting gives a chance for checks and balances in such agencies hence ensuring value for money.
Most importantly, the Public Service Standing Orders are clear on what constitutes retiring in public interest and the grounds for this are well spelt out. Unjustified conflict is not one of them. It’s an invention by COSASE and is totally out of touch with what happens in other agencies.
We should also not forget that Wangadya recently resigned but the Appointing Authority rejected this request, an indication that he sees nothing wrong to have an internal misunderstanding in an organisation like UHRC. It is a healthy occurrence even in accountability or fighting corruption. There is guaranteed accuracy without any room for collusion.
Its also my submission that for someone to retire in public interest, he or she must have cases which may call for further investigation and prosecution. Reading the report, nothing of such cases is being mentioned or even alluded to. So, if they get retired in public interest, aren’t we running a risk of losing huge sums of money in compensation to these Commissioners and the Chairperson? What is their case apart from the perceived failure to greet each other? Have they failed to deliver on their mandate?
I am glad to note that the same COSASE observed that UHRC is chronically underfunded for it to be able to deliver on it’s mandate. Isn’t this the real cause of the perceived underperformance? How do you fire someone you have not given the necessary tools to deliver on his or her mandate? To me, this is the crux of the matter where COSASE ought to have put emphasis instead of going into the day to day administration of the commission.
We should also guard against setting a trap for the Rt. Hon. Oboth Oboth to repeat the chaotic scenes of the 9th and 11th parliaments which passed resolutions ordering ministers Amama Mbabazi, Sam Kutesa, Hillary Onek (debate chaired by Rt. Hon Rebecca Kadaga but resolution ended up being quashed by the Court), and Persis Namuganza (debate chaired by Rt. Hon. Anita Among but resolution ended up being ignored by the President).
In conclusion, since UHRC reports to parliament, I most respectfully suggest the Rt Hon. Speaker Marksons Oboth Oboth, sets up a committee of senior members (he can decide on the number and it’s composition) to arbitrate on the ‘unjustified conflict’ within the UHRC instead of sending away the members. The Speaker has powers to do this and it is very possible. He will then be obliged to report back to parliament on the outcome of his intervention. Otherwise, a “jigger is not cured by cutting off the leg”, a safety pin will remove it and without much pain. LET’S NOT APPEAR TO BE PERSECUTING WANGADYA FOR EXPOSING CORRUPTION BY THE UNPATRIOTIC SECTION OF LEGISLATORS of the 11th parliament. I rest my case & for God and my country.
THE WRITER IS; LONDON-BASED ADMINISTRATIVE, CONSTITUTIONAL & HUMAN RIGHTS BARRISTER-AT-LAW OF THE HONOURABLE SOCIETY OF LINCOLN’S INN OF COURT LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
NB: These are personal views and not necessarily those of the publisher-Editor






