close
FEATUREDNEWS

ANALYSIS: Taking Stock Of COSASE’s Report On Adv Mariam Wangadya’s Uganda Human Rights Commission!

By John Okello Lapok  

The Parliamentary Committee on Commissions, Statutory Authorities and State Enterprises (COSASE) chaired by Kyadondo East MP Muwada Nkunyingi tabled its report on Thursday following its interaction with the Uganda Human Rights Commission (UHRC) chaired by Adv Mariam Wangadya over a month ago. 

The opposition NUP-led Committee, heard from the Commission about queries raised by the Auditor General in his report of the Financial Year ended 31st December 2025. 

These queries were raised in areas of procurement, assets registration and management, Strategic Plan implementation, Revenue Performance, Complaints/ Case management and inspection of places of detention.  

This Committee is mandated by Rule 187 of the Rules of Procedure of Parliament to restrict the scope of its work to; examining the reports and audited accounts of statutory authorities, corporations, and public enterprises; consider the recommendations of the Auditor General relating to those audited accounts and to report back to the full Parliament on its findings.

A closer look at the report reveal a complete departure from the above stated limits to an overlay broad inquiry, effectively usurping the powers of the other relevant committees of the same parliament.

For starters, the UHRC had what auditors categorize as “a clean report” with mostly “Unqualified opinions” and recommendations that were meant to improve and strengthen it.

However the COSASE proceedings and eventual report paints a picture of a dysfunctional institution, to the extent of recommending a forced retirement of its Commissioners.

INQUIRY OUTSIDE THE AUDIT PERIOD 

The Committee stretched its inquiry outside the stated Auditor General’s report when it inquired into funds received by personal assistants of the Chairperson like Doreen Nabatte for activities done in the Financial Year 2026/2027. 

It is a fact that during the auditing period (2024/2025), Nabatte had not yet joined the Commission but she ended up in the Committee testifying and eventually in the report. 

First, the Committee labeled the receipt of the said money as “wrongful” ignoring submissions from both the former Accounting Officer, Margaret Lucy Ejang and the current one, Byonabye Kamadi to the effect that it had been a general practice in the commission and all government MDAs before government developed the e-Cash system for officers charged with conducting activities, to receive funds for the said activities on their accounts. 

None of the two Accounting Officers disputed the fact that Nabatte or her predecessor conducted the activities for which the money was released and had fully accounted for it. Shockingly, the Committee report goes ahead to recommend that they should be made to account and also refund all the monies.

Secondly, it focused on only the Chairperson’s office, leaving staff of Members of the Commission and other staff in the institution, thus raising queries as to whether this was a targeted inquiry against Wangadya as opposed to an institutional one. 

On the issue of closure of human rights complaints, the COSASE Report focuses it’s artillery against Pauline Nansamba Mutumba, currently the Director Complaints, Investigation and Legal Services and former Personal Assistant to the Chairperson, heaping all the blame on her for all the complaints closed. 

The Committee ironically ignores the fact that the Commission has a Complaints Handling Procedure Manual put in place by the Commission of the late Chairman Hon. Med Kaggwa in 2015. 

Under Sections 6.5 and 6.6, the Manual empowers her (Director) and the Heads of the 12 UHRC Regional Offices to close complaints that do not meet the admissibility criteria. In fact, the Director Complaints also sits in an appellate capacity under sections 13.1.1 of the Manual, to review complaints recommended for closure or forwarded to the Tribunal for hearing by the Regional Offices and either agree to terminate them or allow them proceed to the tribunal for hearing. 

The Manual which is available to everyone including the MPs, also avails the complainant an opportunity to appeal to the Chairperson under Sections 13.1.2. 

Instead of critiquing (if any) the said manual which came into force way back before Nansamba joined the Commission, the Committee focusses on the implementer who actually has no powers to review it.

INTERFERENCE WITH JUDICIAL DISCRETION 

Without citing any single case that was irregularly closed, the COSASE report recommends that the Chairperson Hon. Mariam Wangadya be held personally liable for cases that were irregularly closed. It also recommended the reopening of such complaints. A part from the fact that such broad recommendation may turn out to be difficult to implement, it also interferes with judicial discretion of the Chairperson and the Commission’s independence as a whole contrary to Article 54 of the Constitution of the Republic of Uganda. Even at appellate level in Courts of Judicature, judges sitting in appellate matters jealously guard themselves against making decisions that interfere with the trial judge’s discretion because the trial judge sits in a unique position to observe the live proceedings, weigh the context firsthand, and manage day-to-day courtroom matters. 

But in this case, the COSASE committee which interacted with the Chairperson and the Director for only two hours has recommended the re-opening of already closed complaints against those known legal principles. 

Both the Constitution and the UHRC Act mandates any person dissatisfied with the decision of the Commission to appeal to the High Court of Uganda. It would therefore, be prudent for the COSASE to advise any dissatisfied parties to seek that existing remedy. Instead, the report seeks to have the Commission, which has for years been fighting for resources to reduce the existing case backlog, to again spend the meagre resources revisiting closed complaints.  

RETIREMENT IN PUBLIC INTEREST 

The report recommends the retirement of Members of the Commission and the Chairperson in “Public Interest to put an end to what COSASE baptized as ‘unjustified conflict’. 

Just to remind you, the Commission members are Steven Basaliza, Jacklet Atuhaire Rwabukurukuru, Simeon Nsubuga, Apitta Lamex, Chrispin Kaheru, Shifra Lukwago and the Chairperson Mariam Wangadya.

However, according to the law,  retirement in Public Interest can only occur due to; underperformance, incompetence, failure to perform duties, or violations of the service code. Under the Public Service Standing Orders Sections F-R, a Public Officer can only be retired “in Public Interest” due to “gross misconduct.” This very section goes ahead to define what constitutes gross misconduct and that, “unjustified conflict” stated in the COSASE report is not among them! 

The COSASE report recommendation presupposes that there are criminal offences against the officers whom it seeks to retire in “Public Interest” yet it points out none.  Why is the report silent on the ‘crimes’ if any?

OVERSTRETCHED MANDATE 

Apart from stretching beyond the period covered by the Auditor General, the Committee also overstretched its mandate from looking at the financial management of the Commission to delving into administrative issues which are a preserve of the Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Committee. Already, by the time this committee sat formally, the Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Committee had already sat and heard testimonies from Members of the Commission and the Chairperson. 

In fact, one of the MPs tried to guide the Chairman Muwada about deviating from the committee’s mandate under Rule 187 but he appeared disinterested.

It was also baffling to note that the Chairperson Mariam Wangadya received a bit of unfair treatment during the interaction to the extent of being issued with an arrest warrant when she did not appear on its second sitting.

One wonders as to why, instead of issuing criminal summons or a notice to-show-cause why an arrest warrant should not be issued against her for non-appearance, a warrant of arrest was issued. 

Luckily, the lady from Masaabaland turned up herself the next day before the warrant could be effected. 

Worthy noting, Wangadya has been in the bad books with the MPs ever since she whistle-blew the grand corruption in the budgeting process during the 11th Parliament. 

Whereas her actions saved the wanainchi on losing billions meant for service delivery to the unpatriotic MPs, her actions rattled some members.

Unknowingly, Wangadya’s actions led to the President to reject the budget as had been passed and threw it back to parliament for reconsideration after Wangadya’s patriotic expose.

With parliament now in the hands of Patriot Rt. Hon. Marksons Oboth Oboth, the public anxiously awaits the debate on the COSASE report expected next week alongside the report from the Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Committee. 

We are yet to hear from the UHRC on what it thinks of the report. Watch the space! 

Leave a Response